New Carlisle IN Real Estate & Homes for Sale

As you enter this beauty from Michigan St, it's hard not to admire this custom Douglas fir & Brazilian redwood wrap around covered porch. When you walk through the front door you're greeted with the natural hickory hardwood that flows throughout, and the wonderful 9' ceilings. The stunning custom kitchen features Alder wood cabinets from floor to ceiling, solid surface and butcher block counter tops, and stainless steel appliances. As you step into the spacious living room you can spot the built in bookshelves, and reclaimed pony wall caps made with some of the original wood from the home. There are 2 nice sized bedrooms, 1 1/2 bathrooms and a main floor laundry room with built in bench. You can tell when this home was torn down to the foundation, it was rebuilt with no expense spared, with love, by true craftsmen. There is also a reclaimed street paver patio in your fenced in back yard, and a 2 car fully insulated garage off the alley, with plenty of parking.

You'll love this spacious tri-level home set on 2.46 acres in the heart of New Carlisle in New Prairie United School District.Upstairs, you'll find 4 bdrms + 1 bathroom, providing comfortable space for everyone.The main level boasts a welcoming living room, a dining room perfect for gatherings + a spacious kitchen.The lower level features a bathroom, a living room w/ a gas fireplace for those chilly evenings, a convenient wet bar for entertaining + a utility/laundry room.Outside, enjoy the perks of a fenced-in backyard. There are also two sheds for your storage needs + a large front yard that welcomes you home. All of this is within walking distance of our quaint town, brimming with hidden treasures. Find unique gifts at various speciality shops, treat yourself at New Carline Coffee + Sweets + even enjoy a round of golf or meal at Billy Goat 9 + Dine!

Welcome to this cozy 2 bedroom, 1 bath bungalow right in downtown New Carlisle. The home has hardwood floors throughout the house, gas heat, central air, and plenty of storage space in basement and garage. Great location, conveniently between South Bend only 15 minutes and Laporte 20 minutes plus all amenities that New Carlisle offers.

Updated Bungalow at Hudson Lake with Pond Views! Now is the Time to Purchase Your Very Own Lake House at New Carlisle's Hudson Lake! This 2 Bedroom 1 Bath Home has had a Ton of Updates: New Water Heater 2022, New Roof & Well Pump in 2021, Complete Overhaul on the Furnace in 2021, and New Windows in the Living Room (2021). Additional Insulation has been added in the Basement, and the Entire Exterior of the Home & Garage was Painted in 2018! Home Sits on a Nearly Half Acre Lot just Blocks from Hudson Lake and Atop a Hill Overlooking a Beautiful and Serene Pond Stocked with Koi. Make this Sweet Bungalow Your New Year-Round Home or Your Weekend Getaway, it's a Perfect Fit Either Way!

Welcome home to this gorgeous property that sits on over 1 acre in the New Prairie School district! This home has MANY custom features including the tiled main floor entry that opens into the grand foyer with 20' ceilings. Cozy up in the sunken living room with fireplace, the four season sunroom with PRIVATE deck, or the huge walk-out basement that features a rec/gaming room, bedroom, full bath, kitchen with wet bar area, and a huge island for gatherings. The custom eat-in kitchen includes a center island with copper sink for prepping, double oven, gas cooktop, and a walk-in pantry with plenty of storage! Work from home with your private office with views of the well manicured lawn. The grand staircase leads to the HUGE master en-suite with a gorgeous tiled bathroom that includes double vanity sinks, dual walk-in closets, jetted tub, and a separate tiled shower with glass enclosure. The 2nd and 3rd bedrooms are both spacious and share a full Jack N Jill bathroom.

Rare Opportunity! Well established hardware store located in Historic Downtown New Carlisle. This property is one of the largest retail shops in the downtown business district with many possible uses. Or you can move right in and take over the existing business. The property includes 5,360 sf of retail space, plus additional retail space in the full basement. The upstairs has a plenty of space for excess inventory complete with an elevator for easy access. Lumber, concrete and a variety of other building materials are located in a 52x24' pole building that features 2 parking spaces. There is also a 2-bedroom 1 bath apartment that is currently rented to a long-term tenant. Buildings and business will be sold separately or combined

Needs work. Sold as is. Listing info not verified nor guaranteed. Cash, Hard money, and renovation loans accepted. A broker has an interest in this property. property is sold as is - buyer to complete their own due diligence including any code violations that may exist - seller has no information about the property as they acquire it through a tax sale foreclosure.

Welcome home! This beautiful 2 bed, 2 bath house is the perfect place to start your future. With a spacious 1.5 car attached garage and a versatile flex room off the garage, you have plenty of space for all of your hobbies and activities. The large fenced-in yard offers lots of privacy, plus there's an expansive pole barn for even more storage or recreational use. Enjoy outdoor living on the deck overlooking your backyard oasis. For those who prefer main floor living, this home has it all with two bedrooms and two bathrooms located on the main level - no stairs required! What are you waiting for? Schedule a viewing today and make this dreamy abode yours!

Bring your choice builder and create your new custom home! This is a large .46 acre lot in desirable Stone Oak Estates within New Prairie Schools. Mature trees on the lot can provide an immediate sense on home for backyard entertaining. Easy access to US-20 for quick commute! Neighborhood offers ponds and park. Schedule your showing today as there are very few buildable lots in New Carlisle. *Agent--see remarks.

A turnkey business opportunity, this established wedding venue on 10 acres in New Carlisle provides the perfect mix of proven success and untapped potential. Only 90 minutes from Chicago and 20 minutes from South Bend, the beautifully renovated historic barn and buildings offer a charming atmosphere for gatherings of all sizes. Along with the business is an exquisitely renovated farmhouse with 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, and 2,516 sq feet of living space to be used as a primary residence or supplemental source of income. The Main Barn offers 5,800 sq feet of event space for 225 guests, a hand-crafted bar, expansive porch, and indoor/outdoor sound system. Separate buildings include the Welcome Center, Corn Crib (staging site and gathering place), and a Bridal Suite. The Ceremony Site boasts of a landscaped garden, brick walkway, pergola, and sound system. Rounding out the grounds are a fire pit, gazebo, string lights, yard games, outdoor seating, and a lighted parking lot with 150 spaces.

Undeveloped wooded land waiting for its new owner.

MOVE-IN READY! NEW CONSTRUCTION! This floor plan manages to include all the features and amenities! This popular Kelly floor plan offers you an intuitive flow and open concept main floor full of natural light. The foyer entry draws you into the home's spacious living room with open sight lines to the gourmet kitchen with featuring a large center island with breakfast bar seating, tile backsplash, soft close cabinets and a large desirable walk-in pantry. The second level showcases an spacious primary suite with soaring cathedral ceilings, spacious walk-in closet, and bath with twin sink vanity and tiled walk-in shower. The second level boasts two additional large bedrooms and laundry room for convenience. Other notable features include an abundance of storage in the lower level that could easily be finished for more space, a mudroom into the kitchen with built in bench and hooks, main floor half-bath, and a hydro-seed and irrigation package. So don't wait, schedule your showing!

OPPORTUNITY KNOCKING! Bring your new or existing business to this beautiful (former bank) building in Downtown New Carlisle- WITH A DRIVE THRU!!! The current main floor plan provides a minimum of 5 different room and space options to customize. The front lobby has a large counter top area, gorgeous high decorative ceilings and a pristine vault. The drive-thru window can host 2 customers! Bring your vision of imagination to the MASSIVE unfinished 2nd floor with over 1900 sq ft. with SUPER HIGH CEILINGS and wide open space that could be studio apartment, fitness area, storage or perhaps a SECOND business! This property is BEAUTIFUL and your OPPORTUNITY is knocking right now! Situated in the Center of the Business, Restaraunt, and Storefront district in the GREAT PLACE OF NEW CARLISLE where there is an abundance of US Highway vehicle and foot traffic. This offers many potential uses!

Undeveloped land waiting for a new owner to build their dream home.

PRIME RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT PARCEL ADJACENT TO TOWN OF NEW CARLISLE. 5 ACRE GRAVEL PIT WOULD BE PERFECT FOR A LARGE POND OR SMALL LAKE. LAND IS GENTLY ROLLING WITH MANY WOODED AREAS. PERFECT FOR VILLAS OR MULTI-FAMILY WITH REZONING. SEWER AND WATER WITHIN SEVERAL HUNDRED FEET. PROPERTY IS BROKER OWNED. 37 Acres

PRIME RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT PARCEL IN NEW PRAIRIE SCHOOLS. Wooded and rolling, wildlife abounds. Located in the Town of New Carlisle and just north of Dunn Rd/Wintergreen Meadows subdivision. Willing to split into two parcels (5 acres lot 7 @ $99,500 and 11.5 acre lot 8 @ $172,750 for optimal homesites if desired, or purchase entire property for true estate like setting. This parcel has city water and sewer to the site. Could also be ideal for multi-family or villas (multi-family would need rezoning). Broker Owned.