Rensselaer IN Real Estate & Homes for Sale

A fixer upper with a large garage and tons of potential! It has a solid footprint and layout ready for your vision to finish it up. Perfect for investors looking for their next project.

Step into a piece of Rensselaer's rich history with The Alfred Thompson Historic House, an extraordinary landmark built in 1879 and gracefully situated in the Milroy Park Historic District. Spanning over 7,000 square feet, this grand residence offers an unmatched combination of historic charm and architectural elegance. This 7 bedroom, 6 bathroom estate exudes timeless sophistication with its stately facade, intricate craftsmanship, and expansive living areas ideal for both grand entertaining and comfortable daily living. Soaring ceilings, original millwork, period details, and large windows bathe the interior in natural light, highlighting the home's enduring character. The thoughtfully designed layout provides generous spaces for gatherings, multiple parlors, formal dining, and inviting private quarters. Nestled within the picturesque Milroy Park Historic District, this home stands as one of Rensselaer's most distinguished architectural treasures, a once in a generation opportunity to own a true piece of history.

This WELL MAINTAINED 3-bedroom, 1-bath ranch home is located conveniently close to town and shopping as well as restaurants and every day conveniences. Inside you will find an excellent layout with comfortable living space including a cozy gas log fireplace making it ideal for everyday living. All of the HARDWOOD FLOORS have been BEAUTIFULLY REFURBISHED recently as well as resurfaced walls and ceilings in the living/dining area. This property features a BRICK FRONT FACADE as well as a comfortable covered front porch and a fully fenced in back yard! With an acceptable offer, the one year old DETACHED storage garage in the backyard can remain. It would be perfect for extra storage, a workshop, or hobby space. Make this home yours for 2026!!!

This home needs some major repairs and upgrades but could be an excellent fixer upper for someone with skills. Cash Buyers only please.

Nestled on 5 secluded acres in South Rensselaer, this inviting 11/2 story home blends rustic charm with everyday comfort--just one mile from Curtis Creek Country Club and minutes from town conveniences. Vaulted ceilings with exposed wooden beams, beautiful wood floors, and an open concept kitchen, dining, and living area create a warm and welcoming main level. Large windows in the great room fill the space with natural light and offer peaceful views, complemented by a cozy fireplace for added ambiance. With 2 possible 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, the layout offers flexibility for a variety of needs. Upstairs, a loft bedroom features a generous closet, while the spacious primary suite includes a full bath with a jacuzzi tub and a versatile bonus room perfect for a nursery, office, powder room, or creative space. A full basement provides abundant room for storage, recreation, or additional living space. The basement also houses a wood burning furnace capable of heating the entire home, offering an efficient and cost effective heating option. An attached 2 car garage adds convenience, and the surrounding acreage delivers the privacy and tranquility of a getaway while keeping you close to everything Rensselaer has to offer.

Last sold in 2021 for 126K this home closed and passed USDA inspection and financing but this is a BARGAIN priced home now ...granted, it has gone through quite a bit of neglect so cleaning and maintenance is certainly needed and therefore priced and being sold AS IS but was Occupied up until 9/2025 and appears all systems were functioning when vacated but since in September has been winterized, shut down and secured. There is also an unfinished loft area for added sf or storage. Seller will not make any repairs or post home inspection or for financing/appraisal. Utilities are not on and no alterations of the home will be allowed to be made prior to closing. To test plumbing one can have a plumber pressure test but utility activation will not be completed by the seller so Buyers are encouraged to contact Rensselaer Utilities regarding water/sewer/gas & electric. Ask an agent for details on the REO process. Once an Indiana board contract with POF and/or Approval are reviewed and terms are conditionally accepted online by the sellers asset manager a full REO addendum will be sent for client signatures before a complete contract is deemed accepted. REO property and disclosures are not applicable, Agent Instructions are online with a link to offer site and terms. Some additional notes from the sale in 2021 state: "It has new wiring and plumbing in 2005. New windows in 2005. New Siding in 2012 which included tyvek wrap and fan fold insulation. It has a pellet stove that runs off a thermostat.... new carpeting and a new roof. It has a 9ft. X 15ft. metal shed with 5.5ft x 6.5 ft Door." ALL PURCHASERS ARE WELCOME - Owner & Investors ready for immediate bidding!

Pride of ownership shows in this 3 bed 2 bath ranch home nestled on just over an acre. Many new updates include an addition which extended the bedrooms and added a family room. A new composite deck was added in 2020 and several rows of arborvitae trees were added to the landscaping. The new standing seam metal roof and windows both have a transferable lifetime warranty. Driveway is blacktopped and there is a 2 1/2 car garage that also has even more storage. Everything here has been meticulously maintained inside and out, including the above ground pool. This property does not lack room or storage and is a private oasis to kick back relax and/or entertain family and friends. You will see there's a club house for the kids and a fire pit for the parents, with the pool and the property, there's plenty of entertainment for all. There is also a nice sized garden area and a chicken coop on the property. Appliances, pellet stove and 65" smart tv included. Looking for the perfect place to homestead? Look no further, this is it!

Welcome to this beautiful new-construction ranch offering a split-bedroom floor plan and open-concept living, perfectly set on a full 1-acre lot in a peaceful country setting. The inviting covered front porch sets the tone as you step into a bright, thoughtfully designed interior ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The heart of the home features a spacious kitchen with granite countertops, ample cabinetry, a large center island, and seamless flow into the dining and living areas. Large windows provide abundant natural light and views of the surrounding open landscape. The private primary suite is tucked away on one side of the home and includes a generous bedroom, ensuite bath, and walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms and a full bath are located on the opposite side, offering privacy and flexibility for guests or a home office. Additional highlights include a 3-car attached garage, modern finishes throughout, and the ease and efficiency of brand-new construction. Enjoy the space and serenity of country living while still having room to grow, garden, or simply relax outdoors. Nothing to do but move in -- this home is ready to be enjoyed. Offered at 379,900.

MOTIVATED SELLER! WILL LOOK AT ALL OFFERS! Discover an exceptional opportunity with this open-concept ranch home set on a sprawling 5 acres, complete with a detached garage housing a two-bedroom apartment above! This remarkable property is brimming with potential and versatility. Step inside the main home to find a captivating living space, enhanced by a striking wood-burning stone fireplace and soaring vaulted ceilings. The well-designed split floor plan includes 2 to 3 bedrooms, with the third bedroom currently serving as a private office. This room offers exclusive access to the outdoor living area, elegant French doors leading to the main living space, and a magnificent double-trayed ceiling that adds to its charm. The kitchen is a chef's dream, boasting ample natural light and breathtaking views of the surrounding acreage. Tastefully updated with granite countertops, it provides a perfect setting for cooking and entertaining. Retreat to the expansive master suite, where you'll find generous space and additional heating in the en suite bathroom to create a truly relaxing oasis. But that's not all! Above the spacious and heated 2.5-car garage lies a two-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment, ideal for related living, an Airbnb rental, or your creative studio. With its own private entrance and a large balcony overlooking the vast grounds, this space is perfect for enjoying serene moments and inspiring views. Imagine the possibilities on these 5 acres plenty of space for horses, livestock, or even a personal garden! Experience the charm of rural Indiana while enjoying easy access to major roadways for your daily commute. This is more than just a home; it's a lifestyle waiting for you to embrace! Act now and make this extraordinary property your own!

Solid all-Brick ranch located just a couple of blocks from shopping and restaurants downtown. New roof, new furnace, and new kitchen flooring make this home move-in ready. Large living room, kitchen with appliances, full bath and 2 bedrooms provide a nice flow to this home. The primary bedroom is 2 smaller rooms opened into 1 large room with 2 closets. With a little loving TLC the kitchen and bath could be an updated retro look which is currently in style. The large laundry/mudroom leads to the 1 car attached garage. Not wanting to mow acres, this is the lot for you!

First time on the market in more than 80 years, this classic Rensselaer farmhouse offers a rare opportunity to own one of the closest farm properties to town. Set on just over an acre, this well loved home blends timeless character with thoughtful updates throughout. Inside, you'll find 4 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms, a spacious living room/great room, a formal dining room, and an inviting eat in kitchen designed for those who love to cook. The gourmet kitchen features a commercial 6 burner stove, granite countertops, a slate floor, and handcrafted quarter-sawn oak cabinets by Wana Cabinets of Shipshewana. Several cabinet drawers include antique glass fronts for added charm. A walk in pantry with a beverage cooler (included) adds extra convenience. Upstairs above the kitchen, a bonus game room offers flexible living space. Original woodwork carries throughout the home, complemented by brand new carpet. The 3 seasons room includes a hot tub that will remain with the property perfect for enjoying quiet winter evenings with a view of falling snow. Mechanical updates include dual zone heating and cooling, with two new furnaces and two new AC units (2025), all new water lines (2025), an on demand water heater, new septic system (2023), and city gas service. A gas fireplace adds cozy warmth, and the basement features a dehumidifier and professional wrapping. Recently surveyed with markers in place, this property includes only the home no bins or outbuildings offering the feel of country living without the upkeep of a working farm. The surrounding structures on the larger parcel are used for equipment storage and are not part of the sale. Located less than a mile from the primary school and just minutes from all local schools, with quick access to I65, this location combines convenience with a peaceful rural setting. Farm 4H animals are permitted. The sellers have cherished this property for generations have relocated to Florida.

*** AMAZING NEW CONSTRUCTION*** Located in a well established subdivision, situated on a corner lot, this quality built new construction home is ready for its new owners! With a main floor open concept living area, separate powder room, and open entryway, there's plenty of room to entertain and enjoy the family. Upstairs you will find 3 generous sized bedrooms, complete with primary bedroom with en-suite and walk in closet, as well as a conveniently located laundry room and loft area with loads of natural light. Seller incentives will be considered for an acceptable offer!! Brand new stainless steel appliances included! Call an agent today!

Welcome to one of the most admired Victorian homes on Milroy Ave. -- rich in history, unforgettable charm, and thoughtfully updated for the way we live today. Built in 1893, this 3-story treasure offers approximately 3,770 SF of distinctive character on just over 1/2 acre, framed by mature trees and a beautiful black metal fence. Step onto the wide front porch and look up -- the porch ceiling is painted haint blue, an old Southern tradition believed to protect the home and welcome good energy. Inside, you'll find exquisite architectural details at every turn: Two sets of original pocket doors, Inlaid hardwood floors in many rooms, Sun-filled spaces thanks to abundant natural light, Intricate trim and original craftsmanship rarely seen today. The main floor offers exceptional flow for everyday living and entertaining, featuring: A formal living room, parlor, and library, A spacious dining room for gatherings, A bright kitchen and adjoining breakfast area surrounded by windows and a window seat, plus a cozy family room. There are 5 Bedrooms on the 2nd and 3rd Stories, arranged to allow privacy and comfort, along with multiple bathrooms to accommodate family and guests. The highlight of the 2nd Story is the Gorgeous Sunroom. The outdoor spaces are wonderful. Enjoy a large deck with swimming pool, Firepit for evening gatherings, Play fort and the Original Victorian pond, a rare feature that connects you back to the home's history. The basement houses the Laundry, Utility Area and tons of storage. Low Taxes and close proximity to downtown and parks. The geothermal heating/cooling are a wonderful upgrade, and the roof was put on in October of 2025. This home has been the backdrop to countless holidays, celebrations, and story-filled evenings. Now, it's ready for its next chapter -- and for someone who appreciates beauty, craftsmanship, and the charm only a historic home can offer. See if you can find in the photos where the owners paid homage to some original wallpaper!

Discover this Victorian style gem from the late 19th century! Built in 1897, this home features decorative, original woodwork, tall ceilings, and an enclosed wraparound porch that invites you to slow down and savor a gentler time. Inside you'll find 2900 square feet with multiple rooms offering many floor plan options, 3 bedrooms, 2 1/2 baths, and the modern convenience of a main floor laundry room and attached garage. This home also has a private back yard space, and sits on a corner lot close to the downtown amenities. Come see this treasure and discover the possibilities for yourself!

Welcome home to this sprawling 2,185 sq ft ranch nestled in the desirable Sherwood Forest neighborhood on Friar Tuck Cir. This 4-bedrooms, 2-bath home sits on a beautiful half-acre lot with mature trees. Step inside to a bright and inviting living room with bay windows that flows seamlessly into the dining area and kitchen -- perfect for everyday living or entertaining. From the dining room, step out to the cozy porch overlooking the backyard. A spacious family room with a wood-burning fireplace opens to a large deck, creating an ideal space for gatherings or quiet evenings by the fire. The laundry room, conveniently located off the 2-car attached garage, includes both gas and electric dryer hookups. Additional highlights include a whole-house generator, fire pit, and plenty of outdoor space to enjoy year-round. This home in Sherwood Forest offers comfort, character, and room to grow -- come see why it's so special!

Charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home located close to schools and downtown Rensselaer. This home features beautiful hardwood flooring and fresh paint. The living room offers a large bay window that brings in plenty of natural light. Full unfinished basement provides ample storage or future living space. Enjoy the outdoors with a nice concrete patio and a spacious yard. Detached garage and back shed offer additional convenience. Clean, well-maintained, and move-in ready.

Seller is relocating. Welcome to this beautifully maintained gem in Rensselaer, Indiana! This 3-bedroom, 13/4-bath home blends timeless character with modern comfort. Step inside and admire the natural woodwork, soaring ceilings, crown molding, and original hardwood floors, doors that showcase thehome's historic charm. The main floor features a spacious primary bedroom with a walk-in closet and ensuite bath offering convenience and privacy. Upstairs, you'll find two additional bedrooms and a full bath, accessed by the stunning original hardwood staircase. The kitchen includes a large pantry and stainless-steel appliances, perfect for modern living. Additional features include an enclosed front porch, a one-car garage, and a fenced yard ideal for enjoying both indoor and outdoor spaces. With its classic details and inviting layout, this 1900s beauty is ready to welcome its next owner. Don't miss the opportunity to own a piece of Rensselaer history!

Opportunity Awaits! This 2 bedroom, 2 bath home is ready for a new owner to bring their personal touch. Offering a nice layout with spacious rooms, this property has great bones and plenty of potential for updates and personalization. The front, screened porch welcomes you into the Dining Room with a wall of built-in cabinets. The family room has wood burning fireplace, or it could also be turned into an ideal primary suite for a 3rd bedroom. The partial basement offers plenty of storage, and houses the laundry area & mechanicals. The private backyard is a blank slate for your own vision. With its ideal location close to the park, some TLC and modern touches, you can unlock the true charm and potential this home has to offer! Inspections are welcome, however, selling As-Is.

Cozy 3-bedroom ranch will full basement and a 24x24 detached garage with concrete floor. Living room has oversized picture window and laminate floor. The 3 main floor bedrooms have original hardwood floors. Home has a full bath on main floor with laundry shoot. Range, Refrigerator, washer & dryer included. Pool table in basement stays. Home sets on a large city lot 75x140.

54.8 Tillable Acres with frontage on St Rd 49. Approximately 2 acres wooded. Great opportunity to add farm ground to your portfolio. Yields are 150 bushels per acre corn & 50 bushels per acre beans.